The most successful ecommerce businesses and bookkeepers use well-documented processes. Get your ecommerce bookkeeping ready to scale with our free checklist.

Ecommerce Options: Whether to Sell Through Amazon or Your Own Website
Dec 14, 2020

Ecommerce Options: Whether to Sell Through Amazon or Your Own Website

Home » Blog » Ecommerce Options: Whether to Sell Through Amazon or Your Own Website

Estimated reading time: 5 minutes.

Amazon is an ecommerce behemoth.

It started as an online bookstore in 1994, and is now the world’s largest online retailer.

If you’re a small company, the decision to sell through Amazon can seem obvious – after all, you won’t be able to compete with it – but it’s not automatically the best decision for every business. With Amazon Australia set to open early next year, it’s a good time for Australian and New Zealand retailers to think about their choices: take advantage of the Amazon platform, or stick to their own website.

Of course, many businesses use a combination of both, but before you make that decision, it’s good to understand the benefits and disadvantages of each option.

Amazon or Your Own Site? The Pros and Cons.

The Amazon advantage

For more information on starting strong with Amazon, check out our guide: A2X’s Idiot-Proof Guide to Making Money with Amazon FBA.

The cons of Amazon

A built-in market is one thing – built-in competition is another.

  • Unless you’re selling something handmade or totally unique, Amazon will usually have other versions of your product being sold by other retailers. This level of competition can make you feel pressured to keep your prices low, so ensure you have a strategy for success.
  • Selling through an open market also makes it more difficult to add on or up-sell products. Amazon does generate suggested products for customers, which can be effective, but these aren’t necessarily from the same retailer.
  • Amazon can make your business accounting more complicated. As a seller, you’ll receive a monthly summary of your sales, but fees, taxes and date discrepancies can make these difficult to reconcile with your bank account. Fortunately, A2X can solve this problem if you use a cloud-based accounting system such as Xero or QuickBooks Online. Our software automatically translates the data from your Amazon report and feeds it into your accounting system.

For more information about how A2X can simplify your accounting and why our customers call us a “must-have” for Amazon sellers, check out our guide Amazon FBA Sellers Get Better Accounting with A2X.

The advantages of your own site

It might seem like Amazon is still the obvious choice, but there are a host of other advantages to having your own site:

  • Selling through your own ecommerce website gives you a lot of control.
  • You decide what your website looks like, how it works, how much your products will cost, how to manage shipping, and everything else.
  • Because you can make the design fit your brand, a stand-alone site can be the best way to showcase your products, particularly if you’re selling high-quality, upmarket goods. On Amazon, your products show up alongside a whole range of goods at a whole range of prices, which can make your prices look overly high – even if they reflect the high quality of your products.
  • You can also use your own platform to up-sell and add on, maximizing the profit from each transaction.

For some basics to get you started with your own ecommerce site, check out this helpful guide from

The downside of DIY

Doing it yourself means it’s all on you.

  • The control you gain by building your own website comes with responsibility. If you do it yourself, you have to pay for design and hosting, shipping and warehousing, and ecommerce capability.
  • You’re also responsible for updating your site regularly as the market changes.
  • Without the built-in market that Amazon provides, you’re also forced to find your own customers through Facebook or Google advertising, SEO, and traditional marketing efforts, which you can do through employing marketing consultants. This can be difficult and time consuming, particularly if you’re a very small business with niche products.

The bottom line

Every business is different.

Your size, your market share, the type and quality of your products, the number of staff you employ – these will all factor in when you’re deciding how to sell your products online.

Amazon Australia, your own standalone site, or both – it’s really up to you. If you do decide to go with Amazon, the A2X team can help make the accounting side of things easier.

Get in touch for a chat now or start your free trial with us today.

Also on the blog:

The best advice and insights for selling on Amazon this year

There’s a lot to know when it comes to selling on Amazon. In this guide, you’ll find expert tips and advice to make sure you start strong and stand out from the crowd.

Download our free guide

Ecommerce accounting is challenging, A2X makes it easy.

Discover how A2X can automatically take all of your accounting pain away.

Try A2X for Free

Are you ready to succeed with selling on Amazon FBA?

Download our free guide to selling on Amazon FBA in 2022 to learn about:

Amazon in 2022

An overview of the Amazon seller landscape and key changes.

Business models

The playbooks that different sellers use to succeed, so that you can select the right fit.

Selling fees

We break down what it costs to sell on Amazon and the fees at each step along the way.

Fulfillment options

Discover the ways that you can send products to your customer base.

Product research

How to find winning product opportunities to list on Amazon.

Creating your account

The steps to setting up your Amazon seller account.

Listing your products

How to get your products online and optimize them for success.

Attracting and retaining customers

Use these tips to find your audience and convert them on your offerings.

Automation and growth

Important automations and integrations to get your business ready for scaling up.

Where to learn more

Find more places that you can learn what's needed to enable your growth.